May - June 2020
4 June 2020
5 June 2020
4 September 2020
6 October 2020
3 March 2022
Following the euthanasia of a healthy pet dog, Loki and an earlier case in 2017 of Tammy, Louis conducted an online public consultation seeking feedback and suggestions from stakeholders such as veterinarians, animal welfare groups, dog trainers, and dog owners. Over 2,100 people participated in the consultation and over 8,000 comments and suggestions were received.
View the report from the Public Consultation here.
Louis asked the Minister for National Development (a) in each of the past five years, how many dogs have been euthanised for (i) medical reasons (ii) aggression-related reasons and (iii) non-medical and non-aggression-related reasons; and (b) whether the Ministry will start collecting this data if it is not already doing so.
Mr Lawrence Wong (MND): Currently, NParks does not collect data on the cause of death of dogs, including from euthanasia. NParks will look into this as part of its ongoing efforts to ensure that establishments uphold standards of good practice in animal welfare.
Louis asked the Minister for National Development with regard to people seeking to euthanise their healthy dog or cat (a) whether the Ministry will make it compulsory for them to produce documented proof that they have (i) attempted to rehome the animal and (ii) received certification from an Animal and Veterinary Service-accredited trainer that the animal, if aggressive, is untrainable; and (b) whether it will be made compulsory for veterinarians to wait for a pre-determined length of time before euthanising the animal, during which the animal's details are published on websites of NParks and animal welfare groups to facilitate rehoming.
Mr Lawrence Wong (MND): All veterinarians in Singapore must comply with the Code of Ethics for Veterinarians. Under the Code, veterinarians are required to take into account public safety and animal welfare in deciding on the course of treatment for an animal. The Code states that veterinarians must consider other treatment options prior to considering euthanasia. It also allows veterinarians to reject an owner's request for euthanasia, should he or she deem it inappropriate. Failure to comply with the Code can result in enforcement action being taken against the veterinarian.
Mr Ng has raised several suggestions, which we will consider carefully, and in consultation with all stakeholders. In particular, NParks will continue to work with the Singapore Veterinary Association on these matters, and ensure that the Code of Ethics remains up to date with developments in the veterinary industry and international best practices. NParks will also continue to work with its partners to promote awareness of behavioural training options and rehoming avenues amongst pet owners.
All parties, be it pet owners, animal welfare groups, dog trainers, or veterinarians, have duties and responsibilities regarding the adoption and euthanasia of pets. We will need everyone to do their part, even as we continue to update our regulatory rules and requirements.
Louis asked the Minister for National Development (a) whether it will set up an independent committee comprising stakeholders such as veterinarians, animal welfare groups, dog trainers, and dog owners to study the issue of euthanasia of physically healthy pet dogs; (b) if so, what is the Ministry's timeline for setting up this committee; and (c) if not, how will the Ministry ensure that the stakeholders are adequately engaged.
Mr Desmond Lee (MND): All parties, including veterinarians, animal welfare groups, dog trainers, and dog owners, have a duty of care to the pets under their charge. In particular, owning a pet comes with important obligations and should not be entered into lightly.
There are safeguards in place regarding euthanasia of pet dogs. The Code of Ethics for Veterinarians states that veterinarians must consider other treatment options prior to considering euthanasia. It also allows for veterinarians to reject an owner’s request for euthanasia, should he or she deem it inappropriate. NParks works closely with the Singapore Veterinary Association to review the Code of Ethics and ensure that it remains up to date with developments in the veterinary industry and international best practices.
Nonetheless, NParks has received suggestions from various stakeholders and is studying them carefully. NParks will engage relevant stakeholders, as part of the ongoing pet sector review.
Louis asked the Minister for National Development whether the Ministry will include in a set of guidelines on the euthanasia of healthy pets the requirement for pet owners to explore returning the animal to the person or organisation they adopted the animal from before proceeding with the euthanasia.
Mr Desmond Lee (MND): NParks has established the multi-stakeholder Rehoming and Adoption Work Group (RAWG) to take a more holistic look into practices related to the rehoming and adoption of dogs.
The RAWG aims to clarify the responsibilities of the various stakeholders involved in the rehoming and adoption of dogs. This includes pet owners, as well as persons or organisations they adopted the animal from. The work group will consider views from different stakeholders to develop community-based standards and guidelines, including for the return of adopted dogs as suggested by the Member.
We look forward to working closely with the Member and other stakeholders in the RAWG.
Louis asked the Minister for National Development (a) whether the Ministry will issue a circular to all veterinarians to provide guidelines on the issue of convenience euthanasia; (b) if so, when does the Ministry intend to do so; and (c) if not, why not.
Mr Desmond Lee (MND): NParks has a framework in place to regulate the euthanasia of animals. Veterinarians are required to comply with the Code of Ethics for Veterinarians as part of their licensing conditions. Under the Code, veterinarians are required to consider animal welfare and public safety in deciding the course of treatment for an animal. Specifically, the Code provides that veterinarians must consider other treatment options prior to considering euthanasia. The Code also allows veterinarians to reject an owner’s request for euthanasia, should he or she not deem it necessary. NParks works closely with the Singapore Veterinary Association to review the Code of Ethics regularly, to ensure that it is in line with developments in the veterinary sector and international best practices.
The Rehoming and Adoption Workgroup, comprising NParks, animal welfare groups, veterinarians, and trainers, had discussed the topic of euthanasia arising from behavioural issues. The workgroup has developed guidelines to clarify the roles and responsibilities of stakeholders, including for post-adoption support, before a decision to euthanise an animal is made. These guidelines, released in January 2022, serve to ensure that there is good understanding and communication between all parties. NParks will also continue to keep veterinarians updated on these guidelines, through its regular veterinary newsletters and during veterinary licensing briefings.
Resources and discussions on pet euthanasia
TODAY - MP Louis Ng gets strong show of support for stricter rules on euthanising healthy dogs
TODAY - MP Louis Ng's call to further regulate euthanising pets draws range of views from vets
Yahoo News - Tammy's rescuer demands $1,200 in costs and damages from adopter
The Straits Time’s - Ensuring Tammy did not die in vain
The Straits Time’s - No breach by owners, vets who euthanised Loki the dog; no further action to be taken: AVS
Channel News Asia - Euthanasia of dog Loki: Owner feels 'vindicated' by AVS findings, says he lived through hell